My Father The Judge
Medium to FullEcuador wrapperMade in Nicaragua
An Ecuadorian-wrapped cigar with Nicaraguan binder and filler from My Father Cigars. The 5 × 60 Grand Robusto was Cigar Aficionado's Cigar of the Year for 2024.
Scored from published reviewsHow it’s scored
Why it scores 94
Cigar Aficionado: 98 · halfwheel: 86 (average of 2 sizes) · Cigar Coop: 89
No. 1 on Cigar Aficionado Top 25 (2024) · No. 17 on Cigar Aficionado Top 25 (2021) · No. 1 on Cigar Journal Top 25 New Cigars (2017) · No. 7 on Cigar Aficionado Top 25 (2017). List credit runs from 84 for no list up to 98 for a cigar that keeps placing high.
Counts once a cigar has 25 smoker ratings. We're adding ratings from readers and partner lounges.
With no smoker ratings counted yet, critics carry 57% and lists 43% for now.
The blend
- Wrapper
- Ecuador
- Binder
- Nicaragua
- Filler
- Nicaragua
- Made in
- Nicaragua
- Factory
- My Father Cigars S.A.
- Strength
- Medium to Full (per Cigar Aficionado)
Sizes we track
| Size | Length × ring |
|---|---|
| Grand Robusto | 5″ × 60 |
Length in inches. Ring gauge is the width in 64ths of an inch, so a 50 ring is 50/64 of an inch across.
Questions people ask
How strong is My Father The Judge?
Cigar Aficionado rates it medium to full strength.
What tobacco is in My Father The Judge?
Ecuador wrapper, Nicaragua binder, Nicaragua filler. It's made in Nicaragua at My Father Cigars S.A.
Why does My Father The Judge score 94?
It combines 4 independent sources: critic scores, year-end lists and, once there are enough, smoker ratings.
Where to buy
Each button opens a search for this cigar on the store’s own site, with its current price and stock.
You must be 21 or older to buy cigars.
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes a score or a rank. How we make money
Ranked on
If you like this, try
Sources
- Cigar Aficionado: 98 (Grand Robusto)
- halfwheel: 85 (6 x 56)
- halfwheel: 87 (Corona Gorda)
- Cigar Coop: 89 (Toro)
- Cigar Aficionado Top 25 2024: No. 1
- Cigar Aficionado Top 25 2021: No. 17
- Cigar Journal Top 25 New Cigars 2017: No. 1
- Cigar Aficionado Top 25 2017: No. 7
Numbers are as published by each source. We never copy their reviews: read them at the links.