Every cigar we score, ranked

Best first. Ties are broken by the unrounded score, and a cigar held at 91 counts as exactly 91, so one outlet can’t lift a cigar past one that two outlets agree on.

Updated Nov 14, 2026 · 56 cigars so far, on the way to a full Top 100

Early days: a cigar whose data all comes from one outlet is held at 91 until a second, independent source agrees, so a few scores sit at 91 for now. Why we do that

E.P. Carrillo EncoreMedium · Nicaragua wrapperDominican Republic2 sources95 2Montecristo 1935 Anniversary NicaraguaMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua2 sources95 3

Padrón Serie 1926Medium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua2 sources95 4

E.P. Carrillo PledgeMedium to Full · USA wrapperDominican Republic2 sources95 5

My Father The JudgeMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperNicaragua4 sources94 6

Tatuaje BlackMedium · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua2 sources93 7

Oliva Serie V Melanio MaduroMedium · Mexico wrapperNicaragua2 sources93 8

Rocky Patel EmeraldMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperNicaragua4 sources93 9The Wise Man MaduroMedium to Full · Mexico wrapperNicaragua2 sources93 10Trinidad Espíritu Series No. 3Medium to Full · Mexico wrapperNicaragua2 sources92 11Blackened M81Medium to Full · Mexico wrapperNicaragua2 sources92 12Cuesta-Rey Centro Fino SungrownMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperDominican Republic2 sources92 13

Plasencia Alma FuerteMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua2 sources92 14Henry Clay War HawkMedium · Ecuador wrapperHonduras2 sources92 15Liga Privada T52Medium to Full · USA wrapperNicaragua2 sources92 16El PulpoMedium to Full · Mexico wrapperNicaragua2 sources91 17

Plasencia Alma del FuegoMedium · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua2 sources91 18

Arturo Fuente Fuente Fuente OpusXMedium to Full · Dominican Republic wrapperDominican Republic1 source91 19

Padrón 1964 Anniversary SeriesMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua1 source91 20

Oliva Serie V MelanioMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperNicaragua1 source91 21

Oliva Serie VMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua1 source91 22Aging Room Quattro NicaraguaMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua1 source91 23

Davidoff NicaraguaMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperDominican Republic1 source91 24

La Aroma de Cuba Mi AmorMedium to Full · Mexico wrapperNicaragua1 source91 25

La Flor Dominicana Double LigeroMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperDominican Republic1 source91 26San Cristobal QuintessenceMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperNicaragua1 source91 27

Ashton Virgin Sun GrownFull · Ecuador wrapperDominican Republic1 source91 28

Ferio Tego TimelessMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua1 source91 29Brick HouseMedium · Ecuador wrapperNicaragua1 source91 30Viva La VidaMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua1 source91 31Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real NicaraguaMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua1 source91 32

Davidoff Millennium BlendMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperDominican Republic1 source91 33

Joya de Nicaragua Joya SilverMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperNicaragua1 source91 34

Plasencia Cosecha 146Medium · Honduras wrapperHonduras2 sources91 35

Arturo Fuente Don CarlosMedium to Full · Cameroon wrapperDominican Republic3 sources91 36Ramon Allones by AJ FernandezMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua2 sources91 37

A.J. Fernandez Nasser The GoatMedium to Full · Mexico wrapperNicaragua2 sources91 38

Rocky Patel Grand ReserveMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperHonduras2 sources91 39

Macanudo Emissary FranceMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperHonduras2 sources91 40Casa Magna ColoradoMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperDominican Republic2 sources90 41

La Aroma de CubaFull · USA wrapperNicaragua1 source90 42

Camacho NicaraguaMedium · Ecuador wrapperHonduras2 sources90 43Herrera Estelí NorteñoFull · Mexico wrapperNicaragua1 source90 44

La Aroma de Cuba PasiónMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua2 sources90 45

AJ Fernandez New World DoradoMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua2 sources90 46

C.L.E. MaduroFull · Mexico wrapperHonduras2 sources90 47

Alec Bradley Project 40Mild to Medium · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua2 sources90 48Punch DiabloMedium to Full · Ecuador wrapperNicaragua2 sources90 49Olmec MaduroFull · Mexico wrapperNicaragua2 sources90 50Olmec ClaroMedium · Mexico wrapperNicaragua2 sources90 51Highclere Castle VictorianMedium · Ecuador wrapperNicaragua2 sources90 52Foreign AffairMedium · Ecuador wrapperNicaragua2 sources89 53Aging Room Quattro Nicaragua ConcertoMedium to Full · Nicaragua wrapperNicaragua3 sources89 54

Joya de Nicaragua Joya BlackMedium · Mexico wrapperNicaragua2 sources89 55

La Aurora Family Creed Fuerte SolMedium to Full · Mexico wrapperDominican Republic2 sources89 56

Alec Bradley KintsugiMedium to Full · Honduras wrapperHonduras2 sources88

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes a score or a rank. How we make money